[WCF,WebService]比較 WCF wsHttpbinding,netTcpBinding vs WebService 速度(Compare WCF wsHttpbinding, netTcpBinding vs WebService speed)

問題

---

WCF wsHttpbinding,netTcpBinding vs WebService 速度



解決方法

---

基準:
66萬筆資料塞入弱型別DataSet回傳
結果表示:
Client --> Middle(指令從client端傳入service時的時間,可以說是open connection的時間)
Middle --> Clien(從db取得資料以後,回傳到client所需時間)
WCF wsHttpbinding VS WebService

	WCF	WebService
ＲＯＵＮＤ　1	Client --> Middle : 946 Middle --> Client : 270615	Client --> Middle : 968 Middle --> Client : 19831
ＲＯＵＮＤ　2	Client --> Middle : 835 Middle --> Client : 33100	Client --> Middle : 957 Middle --> Client : 19883
ＲＯＵＮＤ　3	Client --> Middle : 878 Middle --> Client : 29743	Client --> Middle : 955 Middle --> Client : 19832
ＲＯＵＮＤ　4	Client --> Middle : 778 Middle --> Client : 289066	Client --> Middle : 953 Middle --> Client : 19690
ＲＯＵＮＤ　5	Client --> Middle : 694 Middle --> Client : 320080	Client --> Middle : 954 Middle --> Client : 19868
ＲＯＵＮＤ　6	Client --> Middle : 963 Middle --> Client : 28066	Client --> Middle : 960 Middle --> Client : 19713
AVG	Client --> Middle : 867 Middle --> Client : 34653	Client --> Middle : 957 Middle --> Client : 19802

WCF netTCPbinding VS WebService

	WCF	WebService
ＲＯＵＮＤ　１	Client --> Middle : 841 Middle --> Client : 19025	Client --> Middle : 968 Middle --> Client : 19831
ＲＯＵＮＤ　2	Client --> Middle : 497 Middle --> Client : 19310	Client --> Middle : 957 Middle --> Client : 19883
ＲＯＵＮＤ　3	Client --> Middle : 820 Middle --> Client : 18943	Client --> Middle : 955 Middle --> Client : 19832
ＲＯＵＮＤ　4	Client --> Middle : 683 Middle --> Client : 18966	Client --> Middle : 953 Middle --> Client : 19690
ＲＯＵＮＤ　5	Client --> Middle : 371 Middle --> Client : 19080	Client --> Middle : 954 Middle --> Client : 19868
ＲＯＵＮＤ　6	Client --> Middle : 207 Middle --> Client : 18987	Client --> Middle : 960 Middle --> Client : 19713
AVG	Client --> Middle : 569 Middle --> Client : 19051	Client --> Middle : 957 Middle --> Client : 19802

結果表示:
同一個基準點上,WCF的執行效能劣於WEB SERVICE,但若改用netTCPbinding的話,則速度不相上下!
但由於netTCPbinding只適用於.net與.net架構上使用,並不像WEB SERVICE一樣的使用XML進行溝通,因此架構使用上需注意
官方說明:
http://msdn.microsoft.com/zh-tw/library/bb310550%28en-us%29.aspx